Sunningwell Parish Council

MINUTES OF THE MEETING OF SUNNINGWELL PARISH COUNCIL HELD ON WEDNESDAY, 17th SEPTEMBER 2008


Present: Cllrs E Bennett (Chairman), T Foggin, D Graham, and H Lynam-Smith. OCC Cllr B Johnston
In attendance: M W Rothery (Clerk)

87/08 Apologies for Absence
Cllr J Russell

88/08 Declarations of Interests
Cllr Lynam-Smith declared a personal interest in the surface water flooding project.

89/08 Minutes of the Meeting held on 30th July 2008
Subject to the replacement of the ‘30%’ with ‘13%’ in Minute 75/08, the minutes of the meeting on 30th July were approved, and signed by the Chairman.

90/08 Matters Arising from the Minutes

79/08 Cricket Field The council considered the reply from Hedges Solicitors to the Clerk’s letter of instructions following the last meeting, and e-mails from the Rector and a Church Warden. Those e-mails had raised the question of the legality of the parish council registering charitable land. It was agreed that a copy of the letter dated 27 November 1991 from the Chief Charity Commissioner to John Patten MP, stating that the Charity Commissioners would be prepared in principle to approve such a transfer, together with copies of other relevant correspondence, to the Rector and Church Wardens.

Action: Clerk to arrange for copies to be sent


79/08 Local roads The Clerk reported that John Beaumont of OCC Highways had informed him that there is an annual programme for clearing highway gullies; the Clerk was asked to enquire when the gulleys between Sunningwell and Bayworth are to be cleared.

Action: Clerk to enquire of Mr Beaumont of OCC Highways


Mr Beaumont had also confirmed that the riparian landowners are responsible for clearing ditches and that Peter Dela of Vale of White Horse DC could help with any problems in this regard.

Action: Clerk to write to riparian landowners, in similar terms to previous years.


The pothole near the entrance to the Manor House is becoming dangerous; the Clerk was asked to chase OCC Highways regarding its urgent repair.

Action: Clerk to contact OCC Highways


79/08 Overhanging trees The Clerk reported that letters had been sent to the owners of Manor House and Orchard Cottage requesting that their overhanging trees and hedges be trimmed; Councillors reported that these had been successful.
79/08 Flood prevention project Councillor Lynam-Smith reported that Peter Dela of VWHDC had informed her that the flood prevention project would be undertaken during this financial year 2008/9. Photographs of past flooding incidents were sought.

79/08 Village footpath map The Clerk reported that a link to the OCC footpath maps site had been put on the parish website, www.sunningwellparishcouncil.gov.uk
The footpath from Bayworth Manor to Bayworth had not been reinstated following field ploughing. It was agreed to ask the OCC Rights of Way Officer to contact the landowner, but first Councillor Lynam-Smith will check the line of the footpath as it appears to be in the wrong place.

80/08 Land adjacent to the Village Hall
The monthly progress report from David Quayle of Hodsons was received and discussed.
(i) It was noted that the Solicitors acting for the Pilkington Trust had advised that it was unlikely that the Trust does in fact own the right of way land. It was agreed to advise Hodsons not to pursue this matter any further.
(ii) It was agreed to pay Hodsons invoice for £425 + VAT for outstanding fees; however interest amounting to £86.89 due to the council can be deducted from this invoice before payment. The Clerk was asked to inform Hodsons that payment was in full and final settlement of this matter.
(iii) Hodson’s advice that the council’s insurers should be consulted before any consideration of carrying out emergency repairs to the car park surface, was noted; the Clerk was asked to write accordingly to Zurich.

Action: Clerk to write to Zurich regarding the insurance position if emergency repair works are carried out.

(iv) It was further agreed that the council takes steps to register the car park land; the Clerk was asked to discuss with Mr Bob Warne the procedure for achieving this without incurring excessive legal fees.

Action: Clerk to discuss with Bob Warne


81/08 Thames Water draft water resources management plan 2010-2036 the council noted with pleasure that the Environment Agency had concluded that the draft plan did not make the case for the proposed new reservoir south west of Abingdon.

91/08 Play Area
The report of the annual ROSPA safety inspection was considered. It was agreed that Cllr Foggin obtain quotes for the remedial work to the concrete swing foundation, for a replacement swing chain, and for one new swing.

Action: Cllr Foggin to obtain quotations.


92/08 Survey of Sunningwell Pond
The report of the survey commissioned by Mike Woodward and Shirley Robinson was discussed. It was agreed that the source of the water problem needed first to be determined, and to this end the Clerk was asked to contact the Environment Agency with a view to their carrying out a water chemistry test. A maximum budget of £150 was agreed.
Councillors expressed concern that the survey was undertaken without reference to the council, and asked the Clerk to advise Mr Woodward of the correct procedure for the future.

Action: Clerk to advise Mike Woodward


93/08 BT Payphones
The council considered a letter from Mr Charles Frost regarding the future of BT payphones; Mr Frost attended the meeting and expanded on the points in his letter. The modern payphone box in Bayworth is scheduled to be removed by BT as is uneconomic.

Action: Cllr Graham to conduct a straw poll at the forthcoming coffee morning.


The traditional red box in Sunningwell is not scheduled for removal but paradoxically is currently not commissioned, and it was agreed that the council would ask BT to repair and recommission it. The council will then consider whether to ‘adopt’ the phone box, in which case Mr Frost who has a particular interest in old phone boxes, offered to maintain it.

94/08 Dog Waste Bin in Bayworth
It was agreed to defer consideration of the proposal to install a dog waste bin in Bayworth to the next meeting, when Cllr Graham will have undertaken more research.

95/08 Finance
The following accounts were approved for payment, and the cheques signed:

Cheque no.

Payee

Details

Total

VAT

1161*

PWLB

Loan repayment

1002.41


1162

B Cross

Litter Warden – Aug & Sept

193.79


1163

Playsafety Ltd

Annual ROSPA inspection

70.50

10.50

1164

Hodsons Solicitors

Outstanding fees (net)*

412.49

74.38

1165

Rod d’Ayala

Pond survey report

212.00



(* cheque 1161 was signed by the Chairman and one other councillor in August to enable the dead line to be met)

96/08 Planning
a) Applications dealt with between meetings

SUN/16237/1 Two storey and single storey rear extension. 2 Beaulieu Court, Pen Lane, Sunningwell: No comment was made as the applicant had advised that it had been turned down by the planning department (NB this was disputed by VWHDC, who subsequently approved it)
SUN/14567/2 Demolition of existing kitchen extension and addition of new two storey extension incorporating new kitchen with new bedroom suite over. Bretton, Lincombe Lane, Boars Hill: Comment: Object as the proposed extension would be aesthetically incompatible with the existing house and neighbourhood.

b) Decision Notices received

SUN/11354/4 2 The Quarry, Sunningwell PERMITTED
SUN/7102/10 Foxcombe Lodge Hotel, Boars Hill PERMITTED
SUN/16237/1 2 Beaulieu Court, Pen lane, two storey and single storey rear extension PERMITTED

c) New Applications

SUN/10425/2 demolition of outbuildings/garage and erection of garage and store. Whitsun Meadows, Berkeley road, Boars Hill. Comment: No objection
SUN/10425/3 demolition of existing conservatory and erection of garden room. Whitsun Meadows, Berkeley road, Boars Hill. Comment: No objection
SUN/20643. Demolition of existing dwelling house and erection of replacement dwelling and garage block. Hillsborough, Lincombe Lane, Boars Hill. Comment: No objection subject to clarification that the 30% increase limit has not been breached. As a supplementary comment the council was concerned at the loss of another fine example of interesting architecture, and asked the Clerk to write to the VWHDC asking them to take this into account in the preparation of the emerging planning framework.

d) New planning regulations governing permitted development.
The Clerk was asked to write to VWHDC asking how the new planning regulations are to be implemented, and what information the PC will be given.

e) Development at 71 Sunningwell
The Clerk reported that he had been informed by an officer of the planning department that the conditions of the planning consent regarding the slab height and roof line appeared not to have been complied with and that this was under investigation by the planning enforcement officer.

97/08 Correspondence
The full list of correspondence received had been circulated to councillors by e-mail. The Clerk highlighted the following matters not already discussed earlier in the meeting.
Item 119 Changes to the draft regional spatial strategy for the South East Cllr Graham reported that the OGBN planned to circulate advice to parish councils on responding to this consultation document. In view of the deadline of 24 October it was decided to delegate any response to the Clerk in consultation with the Chairman.
Item 144 BBO Air Ambulance Trust It was agreed not to make a donation.
Item 147 SOFO Research Centre and Museum It was agreed not to make a donation.
Item 153 Shelter & Bicester CAB invitation to community workshop on proposed eco-town for Weston Otmoor 18 & 25 September
Item 155 SEERA partial review of SE Plan regarding gypsy and traveller accommodation Cllr Johnston reported that this had no impact on the parish.

98/08 Other Business
a) Cllr Bennett reported that Mr Brian Cross was recovering after a spell in hospital, but hoped still to undertake his normal litter duties later in the month.
b) It was agreed that the Clerk write to the editor of Sunningwell Scene suggesting that if anonymous letters such as Parents of Bayworth (summer 2008 issue) are to be published then they should be edited to ensure they are shorter, more balanced and to remove excessive criticism of third parties.

99/08 Next Meeting
The next meeting will be on Wednesday 29 October at 7.30pm in Sunningwell Village Hall.


The Chairman closed the meeting at 9.53pm.



Approved by the Parish Council on 29 October 2008, and signed by the Chairman